Frog Morton and the Curious Tins

L1000364.jpg Frog Morton collection ... Click image for larger file.

Frog Morton line of pipe tobacco … Click image for larger picture.

Frog Morton is a line of distinctive pipe tobaccos from McClelland Tobacco Company, of Kansas City. Among pipe tobacco aficionados, McClelland enjoys a deserved reputation as a purveyor of fine specialty or “boutique” tobaccos, such as their Frog Morton line, or the strong and aptly-named blend “Mississippi Mud”.

The History Channel did a 2006 special on Tobacco. You can always catch a re-run. They included a sequence on pipe tobaccos. History Channel singled out McClelland’s KC packaging facility and delightfully imaginative product line-up. I was pleased to see both the Frog Morton and Mississippi Mud brands featured.

The Frog Morton line consists of four blends (that I know of):

  • Frog Morton – “an exceptionally rich, smooth and dark Latakia mixture for the pipe”
  • Frog Morton on the Bayou – “Smooth and dark and calming, like the waters of the bayou, a relaxing Balkan blend”
  • Frog Morton on the Town – “An elegant, smooth Oriental blend”
  • Frog Morton Across the Pond – “A cool-smoking, fragrant blend enhanced with Syrian Latakia.”

It helps a little to de-code the descriptions in tobacconist jargon.

“Latakia” is a Syrian blend originally produced in the Syrian town of Latakia.  Dark black, earthy and strong, Latakia smells vaguely like a calamine preparation. Smoking it straight is usually considered over the top; it is a blending tobacco.

“Oriental” seems to refer to a quaint colonial notion of the British Empire that the orient consisted of the region of Turkey, Syria and such – what we today call the “Mideast”.

The “Balkans” refer to the mountains and peninsula of southeastern Europe, including Serbia and Turkey.

“On the Bayou” is heavily flavored with Louisiana Perique, a tobacco concoction prepared by soaking tobacco like rotting leaves in a puddle, until black, and then compressed, dried and flaked. The preparation is actually much like that of Latakia in the old world. The results is an earthier mixer. Used judiciously, it also makes for a pleasant and distinctive smoke.

I have used small quantities of Perique in my own earlier blends of “Alex’s Mix”. I also tried adding Latakia to the blend, but, finding the Latakia overpowers the Perique, ended up using only Latakia in my mix.

I find all of the Frog Morton line to be pleasant smokes, and generally will smoke one or the other as a dessert or after-dinner treat. I do prefer the original “plain” Frog Morton, which is not quite as complicated as others in the Frog Morton line, and probably will stick to this original Frog when re-ordering.

I don’t have the lingo to answer the tobacconist question “but what does it taste like?”  What does a honeydew melon taste like? At some point, you just have to buy one and try it. I can tell you that my own mixes (25% Latakia) are pleasant and medium-strong, sweet without a hint of artificial sweetness. and draw enthusiastic unsolicited compliments from perfect non-smoker strangers.

Of the four “Frog” blends, then, it being noted that I already lean toward a less complex Latakia-based blend, I find the Perique treatment interesting but a little out of balance for my palate and sense of smell (you can smell the Perique in the can). Of the Syrian and “Oriental” blends, I know much less, but for my taste the verdict is the same as for “On the Bayou” – interesting, but I still prefer the original Frog.

Frog Morton, then, would be stronger without being harsher, a pleasure to the very bottom of the bowl, a blend I could heartily recommend pipe smokers try when they are looking for something familiar but pleasantly different at the same time.

1,120 total views, 1 views today

Alex’s Mix No. 1 (2008)

 

2008 Tobacco Blend

Alex’s No. 1 mix has changed little over the last year and a half. I shared my blend with my good friend Al M. and he ordered his own. Al mistakenly cut the proportion of HS-3 from 32 ounces to 16, and we found that to be an excellent blend also. I am currently smoking a “half and half” mixture (24 oz. HS-3, everything else the same as 2006). We order tobaccos from the excellent Pipes and Cigars website. The returns still are not in – all three are excellent smokes. When you can change the proportion of the largest ingredient by that much, I think that speaks well for a winning blend!

Name (PipesandCigars.com) Code Qty Each
Lane Limited – BCA (by the ounce) bptlan05 8 1.35
Lane Limited – HS-3 (by the ounce) bptlan16 24 1.25
Altadis Bulk – Mild Burley – J4 (by the ounce) bptalt58 16 1.30
Blending Latakia Pipe Tobacco (1 pound) bptmcc45 1 29.10

108 total views, no views today

Pipes – Letter to a Reader

Hi, thanks for writing. You have a lot of good questions and I’ll try to address one at a time.

First, most of what I know, I learned from browsing the pipe forum http://forum.pipes.org/. It looks like they have reorganized somewhat since I was last there. There is a parent page http://pipes.org/ which also has a lot of interesting links.

I own a Big Ben and am quite happy with it, though it isn’t quite broken in yet. Most of my “regular” pipes are Nording, about which I’ll have more to say soon.

I have an article on ordering my own custom tobacco, and that is what I smoke exclusively now. It is mostly like the Golden you are fond of, but with Latakia added in moderation.

At first I was tremendously taken with the idea of Falcon pipes. Clean, logical, sensible – yet I found my wooden pipes smoke “better” and I am not sure why. I have a number of Falcons but rarely smoke them any more. You can do a better job of cleaning them, but it takes a little longer. You hold them by the wooden bowl, though the aluminum stem does not get that hot.

The Nordings that I vastly prefer are all relatively heavy pipes made of massive amounts of better grade briar. They smoke cooler, probably because of their size and mass – Falcons are lightweights and heat up quickly.

Nording makes a big variety of pipes and styles. Mine are the “orange” briars, a little hard to find, and a little more expensive. They run around $100 or a little under. They are all well broken in and by far the best smokers I own. The lighter, less expensive Nordings are not bad and sometimes you can get a set of 6 for under $50.

I ordered a couple of Meerschaum bowls for my Falcons back around 2004 but never really cared for them. I also ordered a Meerschaum clay pipe. They all taste like they are never broken in – you don’t want a cake in them, they say. I like the cake. I never got the hang of them and abandoned that experiment, though others swear by them.

Switching tobaccos in the same bowl is said to not be a good idea and I found through experience that I agree. A bowl acquires a “flavor” quickly and it takes a long time to change it.

If you like the aromatics, that is fine, but from my experience above I think it would be best to stick with one of them and not jump around, though I know that makes it tough to experiment. I tried a corncob for experimenting, and that was a lot of fun.

I like them smell of many aromatics but they don’t often taste as good as they smell. Many additives make me cough – what the veteran pipe smokers call “casings” I think. Commercial mixes like Rum & Maple are so heavy with casings that, to many pipe smokers, the casings interfere with the tobacco experience.

My own experience comparing “Blender’s Gold” with my own best imitation mix was a case in point. After I made my own, there was no going back. You might order a few ounces of Lane HQ3, try it, and go from there:

Alex’s No. 1 Mix (new) 5 stars

My current order formula: 1 lb Medium Burley from Altadis, 1 lb Lane Limited BCA black cavendish, 1 lb Latakia blending pipe tobacco, and 2 lbs Lane Limited HS-3. I experimented with Perique, but went with the Latakia, which complements and defines the full flavor in a very satisfactory way. I am very happy with this mix and have stayed with it for over a year. I still order my bulk tobacco from Habana (PipesandCigars.com). Despite a respectable stock of other enjoyable blends mentioned on this page, I rarely smoke them.

There is one flavored blend called “Trout Stream” I really liked. But there are really so many fine blends out there, both “straight” and delicately blended aromatics, that my suggestions are just the favorites of one out of tens of thousands of pipe smokers! This topic always reminds me of the youngster who says, “If you like the United States , you should visit my home town” – not because it’s the most representative, or the prettiest, or even a particularly nice place to live, but just because it’s the only one the youngster knows!

As far as protecting yourself against the tar, I tried some of the filters and balsa wood inserts and it just seemed too messy, increased draw pressure, and reduced flavor. At least with the Falcons you can SEE the tar it has condensed out into the aluminum bowl, and you spend extra time cleaning that out with tissue, so I suppose that is beneficial.

A cool smoke helps prevent “scorched palate” which I quickly got from the Falcons, and my dental people lectured me badly. I get less from wooden pipes but there is still some.

We are not supposed to inhale and I don’t, but you get enough “second hand smoke” to irritate. I have developed what they call a “pipe smoker’s bark” over the years, and I have to lay off or cut back if I get a chest cold. So I sure can’t make any health claims for pipes, except perhaps that is does not seem to affect me as badly as cigarettes which I smoked for 40 years up until the year 2000.

I haven’t really posted to my Tobacco page in quite some time, so I might post just my own reply (this one, with no name or address info of course). I do hope some of this is helpful, but the only hard and fast rule I know is experiment, experiment, experiment – and you’re doing a fine job of that!

Cheers,

Alex

96 total views, no views today

Tobaccos – 2

Notes and blends for favorite pipe tobaccos. My tastes are changing! Updated August 19, 2006

Alex’s No. 1 Mix (new) Five stars

My current order formula: 1 lb Medium Burley from Altadis, 1 lb Lane Limited BCA black cavendish, 1 lb Latakia blending pipe tobacco, and 2 lbs Lane Limited HS-3. I experimented with Perique, but went with the Latakia, which complements and defines the full flavor in a very satisfactory way. I am very happy with this mix and have stayed with it for over a year. I still order my bulk tobacco from Habana (PipesandCigars.com). Despite a respectable stock of other enjoyable blends mentioned on this page, I rarely smoke them.

Alex’s No. 1 Mix (old) 4.5 stars

I mix burley, black cavendish and HS-3 golden cavendish in a 1:1.25:2.5 blend (4:5:10). My current favorite. I am using Medium Burley from Altadis, Lane Limited BCA black cavendish, and Lane Limited HS-3. These fresh individual components beat bagged retail blends as mixers every day of the week, turning an “OK” mix into a prize.

Trout Stream 4oz. 3.5 stars

Eric’s Adirondack Series. This is a mixture of Golden Cavendish Slices mixed with a sweet Black Cavendish. Perfect for tying flies or stepping out of your tent on a cool misty morning.

My comments: Mild, no bite down to the bottom of the bowl. Not as robust as anything I mix, but a very pleasant flavor. Excellent aroma in the bag or in the smoke. Seems ideal for the first smoke of the day, or last of the evening. A real pleaser, this has twice been a reorder item. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

Milk and Honey 2.5 stars

Scotty’s Blends. Another house favorite. Loaded with the finest black cavendish and a single malt highlight. Perfect for the cool night.

My comments: Moderately robust, flavored blend gets better as you smoke it. Mild nutty flavor. In the bag, a hint of an aroma like strawberry jam. Not sure what “single malt” means in the blended tobacco context. Possibly a bit much for my liking in a big bowl; might be perfect for a standard 3/4 bowl or a bantam. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

LL 1Q 3 stars

Lane Limited. Golden Cavendish blend but with a hint of fire-cured blended in provides a scintillating taste and flavorful aroma.

My comments: Nice smooth taste, nice aroma. I keep this one around. Best smoked alone, as its subtle qualities will be lost in a reblend. Many find it bland, and I would not argue the point, but it is a pleasant “dessert” change once in a while. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com or paylesspipes.com.

LL RLP-6 3 stars

Lane Limited. Blended with just the right proportion of Golden Virginia and Burleys, the basic blend of Toasted Cavendish tobaccos gets better as you smoke it.

My comments: Lots of Toasted Cavendish gives a more robust flavor, nice aroma in the bag or pipe. Golden Virginia gives an interesting variety compared to golden cavendishes. Although I generally prefer the golden cavendishes, this one is kept on hand for an after dinner or special smoke. LL-7 is a better example of this genre. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

LL-7 4 stars

Lane Limited. Lane LL-7 A majestic combination of toasted Cavendish enhanced with premium Burley and Virginias that provide zesty taste, enchanting aroma and an unsurpassed smoke.

My comments: This instantly became one of my favorites. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

LL HS-3 (blender) 3.5 stars

Lane Limited. Aroma, one of the most important aspects of any pipe tobacco, is the paramount consideration in this blend of Golden Cavendish tobacco. Everyone within smelling distance loves it!

My comments: Sweet, aromatic, wonderful taste on the tongue. As aromatic as they claim. Excellent mixer, this is my staple source of Golden Cavendish. I have already been through a couple of pounds of this. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com or paylesspipes.com.

LL RHQ3 2.5 stars

Lane Limited. A unique blend of Golden Cavendish tobaccos with a touch of Mellow Burleys enhanced with a delicate nutty and fruity flavor for a distinctively pleasurable smoke.

My comments: A pleasant but bland mix. I seem to be leaning to more robust blends. LL-7 has replaced RHQ3 and even RLP-6 as favorite in this category. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

Altadis Medium Burley 2971051 (blender) 3.5 stars

Altadis Bulk Tobacco.

My comments: A great mixer. Much nicer in-the-bag aroma than generic bulk bought at places like Walgreen’s. This is an enjoyable smoke with a nice nutty natural flavor, the best of the straight burleys I have tried so far. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

Lane Limited Light Burley 2.5 stars

A straight mild burley, no bite, burns a little hot unless repacked, and has a nice mild flavor. A good palate cleanser after a diet of aromatics. For smoking variety, I am looking for the “right” straight burley and this is a candidate. Source: Cup O’ Joes

Walgreens Golden Burley (“Blender’s Gold”) 2 stars

This was mentioned in the pipe.org forum: “It has no bite and a decent, if not exciting flavor.” I have most of a bag of this left and will dip into it from time to time. Walgreen’s sells a line of decent, above-average and interesting mild blends, as retail tobaccos go.

Walgreens Mellow Blend (“Blender’s Gold”) 2.5 stars

I started with the Walgreens “Mellow Blend” and instantly left Walter Raleigh behind forever. Adventuresome smokers interested in purchasing custom blends from tobacco houses, or in blending their own from bulk, can do far better. But, for someone starting out, on a budget, or just wanting a decent smoke, the Walgreens 12 oz packagings under the “Blender’s Gold” house label are creditable, economical, and pleasant, reliable smoking.

HGB-2000 Burley & Black 2763051 2 stars

Altadis Bulk Tobacco. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

My comments: Promising. More robust. Flavorful. Lots of Black Cavendish. Nice aroma in bag. A little more bite. I liked this at first but find myself going to the other canisters.

R-18 “Danish Cavendish” 2.5 stars

Lane Limited. Perfect burning quality and rich flavor combine to form one of our most popular blends. dark and Light Cavendish tobaccos. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

My comments: another Cavendish mix from LL. It’s getting hard to express a preference between some of these mixes. Smokes nice even in a brand new Nording. Mild sweetness. Starts out pleasant but light at the beginning of the bowl, progressing to a rich complex near-robustness toward the end, with not a hint of bite or artificiality. Mild.

Alex Forbes © 2005. Last updated August 19, 2006

198 total views, no views today

Tobaccos – Notes and Blends

Notes and blends for favorite pipe tobaccos, January 2005.

Alex’s No. 1 Mix

I mix burley, black cavendish and HS-3 golden cavendish in a 1:1:2.5 blend. My current favorite. I am using the burley and black from “Blender’s Gold” (The Tobacco Center”) retail rack blender bags. These are OK but perhaps not premium. I am sure I could do better. At first I often started with the Tobacco Center “Burley and Black” or “Mellow Blend” packages as a base mix, adding HS-3 and ending up with roughly the same mix by trial and error.

Trout Stream 4oz.

Eric’s Adirondack Series. This is a mixture of Golden Cavendish Slices mixed with a sweet Black Cavendish. Perfect for tying flies or stepping out of your tent on a cool misty morning.

My comments: Mild, no bite down to the bottom of the bowl. Not as robust as anything I mix, but a very pleasant flavor. Excellent aroma in the bag or in the smoke. Seems ideal for the first smoke of the day, or last of the evening. A real pleaser, this will definitely be a reorder item. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

Milk and Honey

Scotty’s Blends. Another house favorite. Loaded with the finest black cavendish and a single malt highlight. Perfect for the cool night.

My comments: Moderately robust, flavored blend gets better as you smoke it. Mild nutty flavor. In the bag, a hint of an aroma like strawberry jam. Not sure what “single malt” means in the blended tobacco context. Possibly a bit much for my liking in a big bowl; might be perfect for a standard 3/4 bowl or a bantam. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

LL 1Q

Lane Limited. Golden Cavendish blend but with a hint of fire-cured blended in provides a scintillating taste and flavorful aroma.

My comments: Nice smooth taste, nice aroma. I would keep this one around. Best smoked alone, as its subtle qualities will be lost in a reblend. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com or paylesspipes.com.

LL RLP-6

Lane Limited. Blended with just the right proportion of Golden Virginia and Burleys, the basic blend of Toasted Cavendish tobaccos gets better as you smoke it.

My comments: Lots of Toasted Cavendish gives a more robust flavor, nice aroma in the bag or pipe. Golden Virginia gives an interesting variety compared to golden cavendishes. Although I generally prefer the golden cavendishes, this one would be good to keep on hand for an after dinner or special smoke. I will definitely stock it. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com

LL HS-3

Lane Limited. Aroma, one of the most important aspects of any pipe tobacco, is the paramount consideration in this blend of Golden Cavendish tobacco. Everyone within smelling distance loves it!

My comments: Sweet, aromatic, wonderful taste on the tongue. As aromatic as they claim. Excellent mixer, this is my staple source of Golden Cavendish. I have already been through a couple of pounds of this. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com or paylesspipes.com.

LL RHQ3

Lane Limited. A unique blend of Golden Cavendish tobaccos with a touch of Mellow Burleys enhanced with a delicate nutty and fruity flavor for a distinctively pleasurable smoke.

My comments: Nearly indistinguishable from my own 1:1:2.5 mix; I think I use a tad more HS-3 Cavendish. This, after all, is a Lane Limited blend. I could be very happy on a desert island with a 5 pound bag of this mix. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

Medium Burley 2971051

Altadis Bulk Tobacco.

My comments: bought as a mixer. Much nicer in-the-bag aroma than generic bulk bought at places like Walgreen’s. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

HGB-2000 Burley & Black 2763051

Altadis Bulk Tobacco. Source: store.pipesandcigars.com.

My comments: Promising. More robust. Flavorful. Lots of Black Cavendish. Nice aroma in bag. A little more bite. Needs to be smoked away from a biting cold wind, in order to get the aroma. Try this in Phoenix.

Alex Forbes ©January 21, 2005

140 total views, no views today

Pipes & Tobacco

Against all conventional wisdom, I’ve taken up smoking my old pipes again.

I like Falcon pipes and a Cavendish-based tobacco mix. Three of my Falcons actually go back thirty years, to the days when I thought Walter Raleigh was great stuff. I would “sweeten” it with orange rinds to disguise the marsh bite and oddly artificial taste. These old pipes, with a decent blend of bulk tobaccos with no additives, are still the sweetest-smoking in my small collection of Falcons.

I’m an amateur pipe smoker, not a connoisseur. Despite having smoked pipes on and off for thirty years, all but a few months’ experience has been with off-the-shelf tobaccos of the corner liquor store variety, and more than a few cheap but interesting pipes. I discovered online pipe stores this year, I mix my own blends from bulk, and it’s a whole new world of smoking pleasure. I don’t inhale. :-)

Current Pipes – Falcon

typical Falcon - Dublin bowl picturedThe Falcon pipe system consists of an air cooled aluminum stem and threaded, detachable briar bowls. You can purchase bowls and stems as a unit, or separately, meaning, you can mix and match from a broad variety of styles. I generally use Pazryk Ltd. as my source for Falcon.

The Falcons are lightweight, rugged, attractive and well built. One could buy just one stem and swap out dozens of bowls. The threaded briar bowls unscrew readily, so they are obviously easy to clean. These pipes are great for home or traveling.

Falcon Bowls

I started 30 years ago with a rustic Dublin-style bowl, an oversize rustic snifer-like bowl, and a smooth straight-walled Algiers bowl. All had straight aluminum stems. I don’t recall the circumstances of this happy purchasing decision. These bowls are thoroughly broken in. They’re incredibly sweet-smoking.

I’ve recently added four more bowls, and have a fifth on order. The smaller “bantam” meerschaum-lined bowl is nice for a quick smoke. I believe these fine clay linings need longer to break in, but are never harsh. When I can afford the luxury of stepping outside for a 20 minute smoke, I prefer the larger “Classic” bowls. Every pipe and every bowl develops its own distinctive flavor, even using the same mix — I have not graduated to the ranks of those who smoke different mixes for different occasions.

Below are some of the bowls I’m fond of. The FP7121 has not arrived yet.

Algiers Smooth Billiard Meerschaum Classic Hyperbole
Classic Meerschaum Dublin Rustic

Falcon Stems

I ended up ordering an individual stem for each Falcon bowl. While this seems to defeat the utility of interchangeable bowls, you can still swap out bowl and stem styles, and I do. Below are a couple of stem styles I use. The bent stem works particularly well with the larger Classic bowls.

Stem- bent, anodized (black or brown)
Stem – straight, gold

Current Pipes – Nording

Nording Freehand - click image for larger picture.

I received my Nording Freehand from Payless Pipes in November. For only $60, it shows excellent construction and finish, a beautiful woodgrain, and has a larger bowl. It quickly became a sweet-smoking pipe and is already clearly one of my favorites. The deeper briar bowl tended to clog, as the one-piece stem joins the bowl about a quarter of an inch above the bottom. As tacky as it sounds, I drop a small pebble into the bowl before packing this pipe. The draw is much smoother, non-clogging, and the small amount of moisture that accumulates does not make the last of the tobacco soggy.

Current Pipes – Dunhill

This prized #4120 Dunhill Amber Root just arrived, also from Payless. Only 5-1/2″ long, it has a standard 3/4″ bowl interior. For whatever reason, it was a sweet smoker from the very first break-in load. As you’d expect, finish and fitting is remarkable. Balance and feel are perfect. I can’t say how happy I am to own this pipe.

Tobaccos

My smoking “breakthrough” was the discovery of golden Cavendish, a popular and aromatic tobacco. You can buy it bulk, and I have found two kinds I like, blends IQ-1 and HS-3 from Payless Pipes – also a reliable source of fine pipes and tobaccos. HS-3 is more or less a “pure” Cavendish. The claim is that no one will not like the smell of a Cavendish. I can see why. Sweet without overpowering, these tobaccos contain no additives or artificial flavorings.

It seems that the most serious issues I had with “over the counter” grocery and liquor store tobaccos was these chemicals, fake flavorings and additives. All these years, I thought Walter Raleigh, Rum and Maple and Half and Half were as good as you could get, and yet I could not really bring myself to really “like them”. No wonder!

My first step toward discovering real tobacco was a prepackaged blend I can only find at Walgreen’s in Phoenix. “Mellow Blend”, a “Blender’s Gold” product from “Master Blenders”, contains some mix of burley, black cavendish and golden cavendish, which is more or less what I am smoking now. I would guess that it has more burley and less cavendishes than I like best, but it is a fine smoke. This firm also markets “Burley and Black” which I am still using as a mixer.

My “mix” is mostly Golden Cavendish, with burley and black added. If I had to guess, I would estimate proportions of 1:2:4. For me, mixing my perfect blend is still a matter of trial and error, but I know it when I get there!

©Alex Forbes January 2, 2005

1,437 total views, 1 views today