I continue to enjoy my Mac Pro (under Snow Leopard) and my PC (with newly installed Windows 7-64). Following are some collected notes & observations.
- Music: for years I’ve been careful to select PC motherboards with the best onboard sound processors (DAC’s). I knew I would be interested in finding the results of A/B sound comparisons between Mac and PC playing the same iTunes tracks in synch.
- iTunes: “PC music” is a hot topic in the high-end audio magazines these days. The thinking is that you have to get an external DAC to wring true “hi-fi” stereo sound out of your PC – and the pros are often as not using iTunes to create their own state of the art music servers – something I’ve been doing for years, using just the onboard digital-to-analog logic.
- And the audio quality winner is: Mac Pro, by the slightest of margins. My PC audio sounded indistinguishable from the original CD to me, or so I thought, so I didn’t see how the Mac could improve on that. Piped through the same back-end mini-stereo and Boston bookshelf speakers, the Mac highs sounded just a little crisper, and the bass just a little clearer and resonantly robust. That’s all the audiospeak you’ll get out of me – it was just enough difference that I could tell.
- HRT Music Streamer ($99): I wanted to see if one of these external DAC devices could really improve my PC audio. I ordered my $99 Music Streamer from Amazon, but it shipped from their trustworthy partner Audio Advisor. There is also a $299 Music Streamer+ with a better Bryston digital conversion processor chip. Art Dudley of Stereophile raves about this thing (the cheaper one) in his review. Believe it or not, all these devices, from $99 to $3,000, get the raw audio input from the USB data stream sent to any and all standard USB ports.
- It works. The HRT raised the PC audio to “indistinguishable” as compared with the Mac. The ASUS motherboard (M2N-SLI Deluxe) hosts an HD Audio Device, an ADI AD1988B, an Analog Devices Audio Codec. (Check the link: it’s amazing what they cram into one chip). You would expect Apple to support top-rate media, so I suppose it’s a credit to ASUS that their more general-purpose motherboard came so close. Art Dudley must be using a Dell.
- I remain unconvinced that $299 or $1295 would get me a noticeably better audio experience. A good DAC is important, particularly if you’re running typical off-the-shelf retail PC’s, but, goodness, there aren’t that many different grades of DAC chip on the market. If you can afford your table wine at over $100/bottle, go ahead and buy the $1,995 Bryston BDA-1 and let me know what you think – in plain English, not in winetaster-ese.
- Speed Comparisons: I’ve been running projects for SETI for years. I’m currently running it on (1) Mac, (2) PC’s, and a laptop. The Mac is pretty much producing as much daily output as all the other machines combined. SETI results below. Click the image for a readable full-size .gif image.
- Machines #5 and #6 are not active. #5 is my current PC, but under the old XP OS; the sixth is the Phoenix machine which only runs a few days a month. Average Credit scores compute lower with disuse. My old 32-bit XP installation (#5) used to crank out an average credit of about 690 units per day, so Win7 under 64-bit is about 1/3 faster on the same machine, and the average is still creeping up.
- Quicken 2010: I use Quicken to manage all the household accounts. Under Windows 7 I found the older Quicken 2009 no longer displayed investment share price in portfolio management, which kind of defeats the whole purpose of maintaining a portfolio tracker. The online Chat folks at Intuit assured me this feature would work under Q2010, so I upgraded, and it did work. Make sure you don’t check Run As Administrator in the executable’s Properties (even if you have Admin privileges): you’ll get the annoying dialog “Quicken does not support the Run As Administrator command”. Everything else works fine. If you do a 1-hour 100% clean uninstall and reinstall, and I did, you still have to un-check the Properties box to get rid of the dialog. (That means their uninstaller didn’t find all old registry entries). Once I figured that out, it all works fine now. I wish their web page could have just said that. Oh, and if you were thinking of migrating to Microsoft Money: did you know Microsoft tossed in the towel? MS Money is no longer offered and support will end soon.
- Sun Gonna Shine in My Back Door Someday Blues: If I ever get into the old Mac vs. PC flame war rhetoric, and I never did in the old days, I hope somebody will just shoot me. Having said that, if you want to install or uninstall a Mac app, you just drag the app’s icon into, or out of, the Applications folder. Heaven help us all if life on the PC side was ever so brilliantly simple.
916 total views, 2 views today