Puzzle Solution
Eden: #1 #2 #3 #4
SummitLake.com logo. Welcome to SummitLake.com, home of original analysis, essays, technical articles, photos and creative writing. Each department on our site hosts and indexes a rich collection of resources on its own topic.
"Eden" Puzzle

Solution #2, verbal method, submitted by N.W.:


"There is another way of coming to this conclusion without the effort of going through a spread sheet, based on finding who never tells the truth first.

"We know that there are 10 correct statements, since they don't say the same number of lies. If the statements are clustered into possible groups we come into 9 possible groups. They are as follows:

1- Group 1, who ate the apple, out of 6 different statements said, 1 or 2 are correct. (2 if the case 'snake ate the apple' is true because it was said twice).
2- The snake is in the garden; out of 2 statements only 1 can be correct
3- Eve weeded the garden; again 1 out of 2 can be correct
4- Abel did his chores; 1 out of 2
5- 'We are not equally truthful' is definitely true so it is 1 out of 1 possibly correct
6- The snake lies; 1 out of 2 possible statements
7- Abel does not always tell the truth; it is said once and is correct
8- Eve prefers Abel; out of 2 statements only one is right.
and finally
9- Snake can't look over the hedge; either 2 correct or 2 false.

If we add up the possibilities of all the clusters except the last (snake looks over the hedge) we come up with a maximum of 8 or 9 possible true statements, which falls short of the required 10. Therefore, not only do we know that snake cannout look over the hedge, but that also snake can't possibly have eaten the apple, or else it would yield 11 true statements.

I guess I would have to again say that this is not how I started the first solution, but I guess I came up with it as I re-thought of a different approach.

Regarding posting the solution, it might be a good idea. You can put possibly correct and distinct solutions there too.

Return to PUZZLE

Please e-mail your comments!

Copyright ©2003 Alex Forbes.

"Rocky & Fluffy Computer Co." and "Talking Crow Productions"

are trademarks of Alex Forbes and SummitLake.com

Comments about this site? Write us: Write Summitlake.com.

All rights reserved.

edited for Netscape and Internet Explorer