|
Coming Out
Talking Crow Productions
|
|
Coming Out, 10 Years Later
|
 
Which One Of These Guys Is Gay?
(Hover your cursor over each picture to see which story they're
telling.)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The older guy and the younger guy are the same
person, but one says he's gay and the other says he's
straight. This should come as no surprise to 99% of the
readers of this page, because, at some age, older or younger,
they've been there.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
What changed? I didn't, but my attitude about
myself changed. That made all the difference in the world.
Ten years ago, I made a decision to acknowledge what I
had known and run from all my life: I was gay. Life started
on December 23, 1989, somewhat late in life by any day's
standard.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I had absolutely no idea where I was going from there, but I
knew I couldn't go back. The whole idea of going anywhere at all
with this was terrifying. I still had the accumulated baggage
and stereotypes of several decades of "conventional wisdom",
but by January 6 of 1990 I had already experienced a calm, clear
vision which carried with it a shocking message of finality. Given
only what I understood of my past so far, it seemed I didn't want
to live at all:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
"There are times
when one is compelled to express an astonishing regret for
having enjoyed life so much, or at all. This is one of them.
I remember the bittersweet picture of Sawtooth Ridge, and
its magnificent five-mile long undiscovered valley, the
whole afternoon's journey laid out before my naive and trusting
eyes. It was the only time in my life I could see where
I was going very clearly and distinctly, and I was not frightened."
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Fortunately for me, I was able to hold
that thought long enough to think about what it meant and
put any urge to opt out completely back with the rest of
the past, where it belonged.
|
|
The first month was "getting used to it",
around the clock, a bizarre and largely treadmill period.
I reexamined my past over and over again looking for clues,
and came up with almost no answers on my own. Every waking
minute of every day was like a good dream/bad dream that
refused to go away. I knew this much: No one should ever
have to go through what I put myself through. I was determined
to find a way to do something about it, too, but this
was more involved than I anticipated.
|
|
|
|
|
|
I suppose that, at some early
point, I imagined that I would just say, "OK, OK, I'm gay"
and that would be it: The past would be revealed, the future
would become manifest, everybody would understand, and I could
just get on with the business of living life in the same way that
I had always lived it.
One must come out to one's self before one can possibly come
out to others. I practiced saying "I'm GAY" in front
of the mirror. How did I know that? I knew how I knew that.
What was different was that I was willing to say that, well, if
what I loved was gay, then I am too. I wrote down things that
I would say to people. Even as it appeared I might have a future
after all, my own questioning of myself and the "wasted years"
was getting more confusing.
It was a wonderful time, but a terrifying time. The operative
mechanism here is that of waking up one morning and realizing
you'd been lying to yourself about something at the core of your
being, and that you'd been doing this for most of your life. How
would you know what you could still trust?
I came out to a couple of close friends. The deal was: I have
something very important I have to tell you, but you mustn't tell
anyone else just yet. The first person in my day-to-day life that
I told was my roommate, who was straight. It took us about two
more minutes to figure out he'd have to tell his girlfriend --
before she heard about it from somebody else first!
Allegory of the caves:
They were supportive, but they didn't know any more about the
gay community than I did . At least one of them had friends who
were good people and openly gay, but I was supposed to be the
"expert". Like some teenager in Moscow or Tehran, all
I had was a dictionary for support. Talk about Plato's "Allegory
of the caves": my friends and I would sit up late at night
talking about what it must be like when people are gay, based
largely on sensationalism we had seen in the media, and we wondered
if I would turn out like "them".
I'm pleased to report that I did. Well, now, as to what exactly
"them" consisted of, the broadest education of my life
was about to begin.
Resource: Like everyone
else, I also supposed that I was unique. Fortunately for me, I
was quickly steered to a peer group, the Pacific
Center For Human Growth in Berkeley, where I did learn that
this "aloneness" I experienced in the early coming-out
process was largely needless. We all start out alone in life,
but we don't need to stay that way. Coming-out should be the same
healthy process of growth which others receive in their own more
traditional growing years.
Disclaimer: Along the
way, I will be sharing observations that could pass for advice.
I'm not a professional counselor, and I have no knowledge of your
personal experience level. If you think that some of my observations
might apply to you or someone you care for, my purpose is only
to share what I think I've learned from my own experience, not
to tell anyone else what they should do.
What you read here may be spoken from experience, but it is personal
opinion still. If, for any reason, you're interested in finding
out more that you'll find here, by all means follow the links
I've provided to other sites.
Back then, my hope was that I would someday be able to reach
out to others in the same boat. Like everybody else, I felt that
no one should ever have to go through, alone, what I had experienced.
Today, I would say that coming-out is not a frivolous decision
at any level of development. It should be considered carefully
and planned in advance, because far more than personal comfort
can hang in the balance. This is a once-in a lifetime decision,
so there is no valid way to substitute your arm-chaired gut feelings
for talking, in a safe environment, with others who have been
through it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Alone, or in the company of peers, everybody
has to do their own work. There are no magic incantations,
and few ritual healing formulas.
|
|
With the young, the basic coming-out issues generally
are learning to embrace reality, and dealing with one's
parents and peers. Coming out at a later stage of life
brings other tradeoffs. One has built up a baggage of
the past to reconcile, to shake.
I shook it. I didn't have much choice. I didn't feel
I had much time. I saw myself then as having wasted decades
of my own life in lies and self-deception. I largely disagree
with this analysis now, which is leading us to a perspective
I fervently hoped, 10 years ago, I would be able to provide
some day.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I think I have that perspective now, but it's only what worked
for me. I did my own work, but my situation needed the ears and
experiences of peers who, like myself, had ducked sexual orientation
issues for many years. For others, coming out as teens or young
adults, there is less past to regret and reconcile.
Ten years ago, I had a whole laundry list of discoveries to share
with the world. Today, I am not so sure what I want to say.
I've said most of it in these pages, and in "Ask
Alex", a little-known corner of a small La Parola, enclosed
in a small web site in a billion megabytes of world wide web.
La Parola has been on the web for around five years, and has been
a club newsletter for longer than I've been editor, which is about
nine.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
For the most part, I have always avoided references
to my own personal experience in these pages in the past,
though that is the preferred method through which gays
shared issues and experiences in all the peer groups I
attended and facilitated. I still think a newsletter is
not necessarily the proper forum for a journal of personal
experiences and tribulations.
On the other hand, it's never been my intent to keep
my own personal experience a secret, as if I am "above
all that" now. I have written extensively and passionately
about gay issues of national scope, and I have written
about national and world issues because I am a citizen,
but I am also a gay man, and part of that community,
and always will be.
I think that on the tenth anniversary of my own coming-out,
it is time to say something about who I am and what
I've experienced -- personally.
|
|
|
|
|
|
I still feel an alarming impatience with questions like "what
does it feel like to be gay?", an impatience not entirely
in keeping with the training of a person who went on to become
a peer group facilitator for five years.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Part of my pledge to myself ten years ago was
that I would never forget. What has happened instead is
that I have moved on, as we all must. I have acquired
skills and met challenges that would have been unthinkable
back then, for a variety of reasons, and yet I think it
would be a mistake for me to represent to myself, or to
you, that "coming-out" has lost its significance.
It never does. Only a beginning, it is a fundamental rite
of gay passage, with many parallels in other segments
of our society.
|
|
|
|
|
|
It is a habit of mine to get the bad news out of the way first.
Believe it or not, the initial weeks were the only bad news I
got. If they were rough on me, please understand that the chickens
were coming home to roost, as I always knew they would one day.
I had the decisions and choices I made as a young adult to thank
for that. Please don't read from this narrative a generalized
pattern of how people come to grips with their sexual orientation.
People react differently to self-discovery and personal change,
very often much more realistically than I did. My situation was
not uncommon, though, particularly among those who have a past
to reconcile, and among those who do not have a supportive peer
group from the very beginning.
I fit both categories. Once I was able to laugh again, I started
a gag that, of the three conditions known to be leading causes
of suicide (change in employment, change in residence, and loss
of loved one), I had five of them.
Whoever you may be, you should carry the message that it can
be dangerous for people to try to "go it alone". You
can avoid a crisis by steering yourself, or any friend or family
member beginning a "coming-out" process, to a local
group of people who are trained and experienced in the issues
that face us at this point. This web site is full of links to
other gay/lesbian/bisexual/transgender resources (so often abbreviated
as "glbt").
Those
links lead to links greater still, and greater still, until even
the densest couch potato among us begins to see there's no refuge
in the "I'm unique and alone" theories that we so often
concoct to comfort ourselves in our refusals to see.
Resource: Because almost
any local phone book or web index will have a listing for Parents
and Friends of Lesbians And Gays (PFLAG), I would happily
recommend one begin there for resources.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I also recommend a firm resolve to avoid
any delay in meeting with people who actually ARE gay or
lesbian. The question that got me to agree to check out
the Pacific Center was this:
|
|
"So, what are you going to do now that
you're gay? Sit on that couch for the rest of your life
talking about it? Like you did all those years the story
was that you were straight?"
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
My friends remained supportive, my peer group was outstanding.
I learned -- I learned a lot, and very quickly, although I always
suspected I was trying to make up for lost time. I was soon riding
the crest of an information supernova. It was a fascinating time.
Along with everything else, I watched myself watching others grow.
Mostly, I watched myself watching and questioning myself. Where
was this headed?
Life After Coming Out
What
I still want to work up to, today, is the projection of a sense
of "what it is like to be gay" that makes sense to community
newcomers and reactionary old non-gay observers at the same time.
After the novelty of coming-out issues have worn off, is there
life after that? Of course there is. Other than by way of
example, my own story isn't important. It isn't even particularly
illustrative of the process, which is as varied as are we humans
ourselves.
I also want to reassure anyone just starting the coming-out
process, as I was then, that, yes, you do "get over it".
As you re-discover and reinvent yourself, a new world opens up
to the "real you" that you were hiding from all those
years.
The biggest surprise for me was that it wasn't the "gay
world" that opened up, though that happened too. The "real
world", the greater community at large, opened up; it became
possible to me in a way it never had seemed accessible before.
Once the newness of being an "out" gay person fades,
many people report an accelerated personal growth and achievement
they never thought possible before.
"Born Again": There are many valid reasons why this
should be so; for example, we must become comfortable with ourselves
before we can truly be comfortable with others. This agonizing
old homily is just one of several cited when peers report a feeling
of being "born again". This phrase is almost always
used, though in the same breath it is almost always repudiated
because of its expropriation by fundamentalist religious sects.
After 10 years, what do I think "it's
really like to be gay"?
As I confessed earlier, my first reaction would be to ask readers:
what do you really want to know? Modest exposure to various schools
of rhetoric suggests a turn-around response like "what do
you want for an answer?". In all honesty, experience in life
says that more is required. People, gay or straight, just starting
out on issues like "what is gay", have a legitimate
need for straightforward answers. I should surely know.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
Is it like waiting for the verdict of the
Matthew Shepard murder trails, or the fate of the Mars Polar
Lander, or the election returns? Is it like calling up your
honey on a trip just to say "I love you!", or
is it like slow-dancing to the Tennessee Waltz?
|
|
|
 |
Is it like Al Stevens' Cram Course on C/C++,
is it like riding motorcycles or flying twin Cessnas, is
it like troubleshooting complex COBOL systems and db2 database
calls, or is it like sitting under the shade of a live oak,
on a green hilltop, in the spring, and looking out upon
all of the neighboring counties and the mountains beyond?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
Suppose, for the moment, that you happen
to be straight, married and still hopelessly in love, and
hold down a full-time career in a profession you love. You
have two kids, who are growing up fast, but you love them
and think that you can help guide them along the path to
a happiness of their own finding. You drive a two-year old
sedan, you share a family cat with every other neighbor
that feeds it too, and, when time permits, which is seldom
often enough, you like to get away for a vacation or a game
of golf or a round of cards with the boys.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Answers: all of the above. Yes, that's
what it feels like to be gay.
The point is not whether or not you happen to have a wife or
kids. The point is whether you're happy with what you're doing,
with the people in whose daily activities you immerse yourself
every day, and with the directions that life is taking you. That's
neither a gay issue, nor a straight issue. It's just an issue
underlying all of the decisions and choices we all make.
If you prefer to make those decisions yourself, rather than letting
the tide of events and the preferences of others make them for
you, well, then, I guess that's why we're here talking about this
together.
Being gay is like being anybody
else. Being gay is like being whoever you were "before".
Being gay is like becoming whoever you are now.
If you are gay, then being gay is being yourself; being yourself
is being true to your identity. Only when you understand that,
whether you happen to be gay or not, can you then appreciate the
distinctions and diversity that our society's different cultures
really do have to offer us. First and foremost, we are all human
beings whose personal abilities, strengths, needs and likes override
manufacturered differences among us -- of race, sex or sexual
orientation, religion or ethnic background.
It still seems to me really surprising that there could be any
point in saying that. We only need pick up the newspaper to see
that a significant percentage of our population truly doesn't
grasp basics that most of us sensed in grade school.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
According to the dogma of prejudice, a "little
red wagon" is an object defined into the class "red",
whose distinguishing property is that, attached to it,
is a small four-wheeled vehicle with a handle for pulling.
As regards other small, four-wheeled vehicles with handles
for pulling, which may happen to be yellow, brown or pink,
it is thought that those objects could not possibly be
certified as wagons.
|
|
 |
If you could go back ten years, what would be your best advice
to yourself? I'll tell you what: I never considered myself prejudiced,
but "coming-out" was not only the best thing that ever
happened to me, it was an incredible and well-deserved eye-opener.
There's schools of thought where it's still considered witty
to mock statements like "you don't know what it's like to
be black." The cutting repartee goes something like this:
"well, of course I don't know what it's like to be black,
and even if I did, how am I supposed to believe that would change
the axiomatic truthes as I know them?"
The more ingenuous newcomer to this (predominantly white) group,
not knowing any better yet, may think: "well of course I
know what it's like to be black; it's just like being me, only
with dark skin!"
At a certain level of maturity it may seem convenient to assume
that what we know from personal experience is everything we need
to know about personal experience, but that is a convenient fiction,
part of the baggage of "conventional wisdom" which regularly
paralyzes even some of the best of folks from the neck up.
Both groups miss the point, though the first group dismisses
it deliberately.
Denial of wrongdoing, denial of
personal complicity, is not the same thing as accepting personal
responsibility for knowing the truth and acting appropriately.
The truth is that most of us find comfort in ignoring injustice
when it does not affect us personally.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In defense
of me and mine, we are righteous and omnipotent; in
defense of the person next door, we are powerless
and without jurisdiction.
Most cutting-edge leaders
and thinkers on individual rights remain in deep denial
about who should have them, or, if everyone has rights,
whether systematic rights violations can possibly
be a system-wide problem. Often, they acknowledge
that injustices "do" occur, but insist that
this should not affect the justice of The Movement,
which has always ignored those issues in the past.
|
|
|
|
|
|
In another's shoes:
What I learned about this is not very complicated, and not
very difficult, though the first step is to actually do it,
and that was difficult for me to choose. I learned to want to
know what it is like to walk in another's shoes.
I had a personal incentive to acquire this knowledge. In a
way, I had been preparing for this all my life, and I guess
I always knew why. While this new outlook did not change my
basic views of right and wrong, it did influence my willingness,
and my ability, to listen to what others have to say. This made
it possible for me to look for evidence that others may have
a story that we need to listen to -- and understand.
The "personal awareness level" of Americans is maturing
rapidly. This is largely due to exponential growth in information
technology, and to a growing desire to "live and let live".
Call this "tolerance", "understanding" or
just growth -- but we as a nation are now examining issues such
as racial quotas and "Driving While Black" arrests
with a skepticism that was never understood before.
Our ability to challenge, and correct, our own courses will
have far-ranging spin-off benefits in the home, school and workplace.
And the primary beneficiary is the listener.
Looking Back One Last Time:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I really didn't have much more to say. This
wasn't meant to be an expose or "my story"
in the first place. It was a remarkable passage, a remarkable
ten years. Looking back one last time:
|
|
About a year prior to December 23, 1989,
I do remember distinctly one afternoon realizing that
I had run out of options, and was living from day to day.
Every day was getting a little more unendurable. A five-year
love affair, the only one I had ever known, had ended
some years earlier. I was unhappy with my work. Relations
with friends were strained, both with wear and tear, and
with mounting issues I had always been able to laugh off
in the past. The only peace I could find was in long solo
hikes in the hills and back country. I saw no more "once
in a lifetime" windows in my future. In fact, I saw
no future at all.
Today, I am grateful for a wonderful home life with
my partner and lifetime companion. We celebrated our
ninth anniversary together in October. I work for a
good company in a job I really enjoy. Interests old
and new have blossomed into more projects, quests and
callings than I really need, but I enjoy every one of
them immensely. I derive deep personal satisfaction
from my modest accomplishments. Life IS exciting, and
it has truly been wonderful.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Were my fortunes to change, I have no regrets, and few fears
for my ability to surmount difficultly. I have found myself
able to develop latent skills and abilities that were simply
inaccessible "before". Do I attribute this to my "coming-out"
decision?
Yes, that was the jump-start that got the motor going again.
Sure, I might have coasted for a while longer as a compartmentalized
creature of habit. What I am saying here was that I was compartmentalized,
self-crippled if you will, and that I knew that then.
House of Cards:
Feel free to armchair this all you want, but what I see now,
speaking strictly about my own personal experience, is that
I intentionally limited the direction and scope of my ability.
Some areas are obvious: expressions of affection or love were
dangerous places to go. Other areas, such as in the professional
arena, may not be so obvious. Let's just affirm the obvious:
compartmentalization doesn't work; it's a death sentence by
slow shut-down.
While I guarded against a danger that this juggling act could
undermine my integrity, my "white plume", this clever
strategy accelerated the undermining of my integrity. It depended
on my being willing and able to live without love or affection,
a prospect I found unliveable.
I believe I had hoped that, by containment of sexual orientation
issues, I could "slide by" on my other strengths.
The developing problem, as I see it now, became that increasingly
I was unable or unwilling to distinguish between my integrity
as a real strength, and my integrity as the facade and fraud.
What the hell, I said, to what could I look as a reference point,
in order to prove the difference?
You can't have your integrity and lie about it too. I am truly
grateful that those dark days are now forever in the past for
me.
In a peer group session one night, I volunteered that I still
felt bitter and angry about all the empty, hollow years that
I had wasted. The group facilitator, who was also a respected
leader in the gay community, disagreed with me: he, himself,
had "come out" at the age of seventy.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
To most others, doing what I did about
it was the obvious course, but to me it seemed a miraculous
good fortune. In the free-thinking enclaves of the
San Francisco Bay Area, most people are today able
to deal with coming-out issues in their teens or early
twenties. It is NOT the same all over the United States,
where there are still pockets of "deep cover"
-- for the protection and comfort of those who like
"all the answers" handed to them by highly
sectarian interpretations of two thousand year old
religious traditions and cultural shibboleths.
|
|
|
|
|
|
- I have heard and read many times the speculation that
everybody, at least once in their lifetime, must face a
decision to either overcome an obstacle, or stop growing
and die.
- Most of us who believe this, also believe that choice
is made consciously at some level.
- While there can be little doubt in my personal experience
that this is so, we have all known people who stopped growing
decades ago, yet who refuse to let go of a world filled
(for them) with pain, suspicion and ugliness.
- The will to live is factory standard equipment; the will
to live a life of one's own choosing is, by definition,
a choice.
I'll always be glad I took the second choice. A small step
for mankind, perhaps, but a giant leap for me.
Things That I Learned:
- Coming-out is an individual decision and process, and
not necessarily for everybody
- I was very fortunate to have a great support group and
learn quickly
- Our personal need for lifelong human growth knows no boundaries
of status or denomination
- When you want to find out, ask those who know, but do
your own homework
- I was able to make other major choices to improve the
quality of my life
- Gays are not the only people who face hostility and adverse
opinion
- The most important thing in life is to live it fully
- Good friends are an essential part of a good life
- Loving life is wonderful, and sharing this with someone
you love is everything
Friends:
There is one other great weight that was lifted from me.
II would like to finally touch upon it here. I wrote earlier
of relationships with friends that had become strained. Most
of those friendships have changed in the intervening years,
but that is often because I simply pursued friendships based
on common values and enjoyment, rather than on traditional
roles created in formative years.
Other wonderful friendships withered because of distance
or changes of circumstance, including, I am sure, my own.
I have found a new interest in once again cultivating some
(but not all) of the old friendships. I think there are at
least a couple of valid reasons for this change of heart.
For one, there was a lot of value in some of the old friendships
that was never compromised. For another, the good in the "old
me" has purpose beyond my own amusement.
Finally, since I now see a difference between friends who
are chosen and earned, and those we find ourselves bound to
in that lot in life that we were cast into together, I've
lost interest in blaming others for the wrongs that we bought
into in the old days. I bought into them too. I made, and
unfairly minimized, more than my fair share of mistakes.
Along the way, I also deeply hurt, or walked away from, several
wonderful people because I had a crush on them. From the others,
I would sometimes tolerate manipulation and abuse as a form
of self-blackmail.
While I have no interest in going back to any of those roles,
the rancor and hurt has gone from those memories. I don't
"hate" anyone any more.
A friend once said of another, a former acquaintance who
had fallen on really bad ways and then died suddenly, "I'm
glad he's dead. I always hated him."
What we hate, is that within ourselves which renders us powerless
to deal effectively with threats to our own values.
When there has to be a better way, there is.
It's been a wonderful decade
It's truly been a wonderful decade for me, by far the best
ten years of my life. I hope for many more decades like this
one, as we sit talking here, on the eve (as it happens) of
the Year 2000 millennium.
In Thanks ...
I want to thank my permanent partner Bob, and our many wonderful
and supportive friends, for sharing so many insights and experiences
on this truly remarkable journey. May we enjoy many more such
adventures together!
So, as we all turn into the next millennium, who knows what
kind of future our choices will bring? For my own part, I
feel confident that for better (or even for worse), the experiences
and knowledge I've gained will be a source of comfort, and,
I hope, security in our coming years. Not only am I glad I
made a choice to live, I'm glad I chose to live a life of
my own choosing.
Whoever you are, wherever you are going, thanks for following
this with me. You may agree or disagree with particulars of
my experience here, but, as always at SummitLake.com, I hope
that you found something of your own here that you can take
with you. Be well, and go in peace.

December 7, 1999


copyright 1999 by Alex Forbes and Talking
Crow Productions
this document last modified 10/27/2002
8:58
PM
|
|